DrinkMate vs SodaStream Fizzi: Which Soda Maker Or Carbonator Is Best To Buy?

Do you love to enjoy soda? If yes, then what about the potential health risk associated with a soda can? Fortunately, you can enjoy the same carbonation without compromising your health by drinking sparkling water or soda water. Now you may be interested in a soda maker. Therefore, we or going to compare two dominating carbonating machines: DrinkMate vs SodaStream Fizzi. Let’s see the functionalities, ups, and downs of both the DrinkMate and the SodaStream Fizzi to identify which option is better.

DrinkMate vs SodaStream Fizzi: Side By Side Comparison Chart

ProductDrinkMateSodaStream Fizzi
ImageDrinkMateSodaStream Fizzi
Compatible CO2 Cylinder60L CO2 (DrinkMate or SodaStream)60L CO2 (SodaStream)
Bottles Compatibility1 litter reusable carbonating bottle0.5L and 1L reusable carbonating bottles
Carbonating Bottle Connection TypeSnap-lockSnap-lock
Carbonating Bottle MaterialBPA-free PlasticBPA-free Plastic
How To Fizz (Carbonation Process)Manual Pump ActionManual Pump Action
Carbonation Time10 to 30 seconds10 to 30 seconds
Include Carbonating CylindersNoYes
Selectable Fizz LevelsNoNo
LED Fizz IndicatorsNoNo
Dishwasher SafeNoNo
Required ElectricityNoNo
Easily PortableSomewhat YesNo
Available ColorsMatte Black, Classic White, Royal RedBlack, White, Icy Blue, Red, Rose Gold
Dimensions
(L x W x H)
8 x 5 x 16 inches7.9 x 5 x 17 inches
Weight3.8 pounds6.1 pounds
Warranty2 Years3 Years
What You GetDrinkMate sparkling water & soda maker, Fizz infuser, and 1 Litter reusable BPA-free carbonating bottleSodaStream sparkling water & soda maker, 1 Litter reusable BPA-free carbonating bottle, and a Carbonating cylinder
PriceDrinkMate sparkling water SodaStream sparkling water

DrinkMate vs SodaStream Fizzi: Similarities

Generally, the soda drinks you buy from your grocery shop contain harmful chemicals and an unhealthy and excessive amount of sugar that can pose health problems to you. Therefore health-conscious people use light or zero variants of sodas that still contain some toxic elements. But sparkling water (also known as soda water) does not contain sugar which translates to no potential health issues.

However, sparkling sodas are tasteless as the water is. But don’t worry because manufacturers of these carbonator machines already consider this matter and provide flavored syrups that you can add to your carbonated water to satisfy your taste buds. For instance, you can buy fruity flavors such as lemon, orange, cucumber, mango, and peach bubbling drops.

Both DrinkMate and SodaStream are inexpensive and the most popular choices among other soda makers available in the market. Although DrinkMate enters recently in the market, it took modern and efficient models into the race. Both carbonator machines are quite similar and are worth your consideration. Let’s look at their similar features closely!

Compatible CO2 Cylinder For DrinkMate And SodaStream

Compatible CO2 Cylinder for DrinkMate and SodaStream

Generally, custom soda makers use CO2 that comes in small tanks and canisters to produce sparkling water. Both the DrinkMate and SodaStream can use a 1L cylinder of carbon dioxide (CO2). Both companies provide carbonating cylinders. However, SodaStream is a more recognized company than DrinkMate. Even you can use SodaStream’s CO2 cylinder with the DrinkMate soda maker.

You can start enjoying soda water immediately with the SodaStream Fizzi machine because it comes with a carbonating canister (more detail is in the differences section).

Are They Have A Manual Or Automatic Carbonation Process?

Oops! Both the DrinkMate and the SodaStream don’t come with an automatic carbonation process. Instead, a manual pump action produces fizzy water in these custom soda maker machines. So, you don’t need any batteries or electricity to operate these machines and they work fine on your countertop without any outlet (One major plus point of a manual pump action).

However, you can’t set the level of fizziness/carbonation of your soda water with a manual pump action (nothing comes without a downside). So, use the guess and trial technique every time to get the desired level of fizz while using both soda makers.

The DrinkMate And SodaStream Fizzi Produce High-quality Carbonating Water

The DrinkMate And SodaStream Fizzi Produce High-quality Carbonating Water

Both the DrinkMate and SodaStream Fizzi provide almost identical quality of carbonation because both utilize the same CO2 cylinder and manual process. So, essentially the carbonation process is the same. You get high-quality sparkling beverages with both carbonators. The only thing that matters is your preferred level of fizziness.

However, both machines follow different actions to make carbonate water (further detail described in next section).

What’s The Difference Between SodaStream And DrinkMate?

Overall, both machines give the same level of fizziness. But there is a clear winner between them which perform better than the other.

Now, it’s time to explore the differences between these sparkling water makers to know how both DrinkMate and the SodaStream Fizzi are unique in their way. Read on to discover a better choice in terms of cost and other characteristics.

Difference Between Their Carbonating Cylinder Cost

Both DrinkMate and SodaStream Fizzi are inexpensive soda makers. However, when we talk about CO2 cylinders, they differ in terms of cost.

DrinkMate

DrinkMate is inferior in this category to the Fizzi. You don’t get a CO2 cylinder with this soda maker and need to buy a separate one. Moreover, their cylinders are available at a higher price tag which puts DrinkMate at a great downside. You must pay $30 to $45 for a single 60L CO2 cylinder.

We suggest using the carbonating cylinders from SodaStream as they are compatible with DrinkMate and cost you less.

SodaStream Fizzi

In contrast, the SodaStream comes with carbonating cylinder out of the box. Moreover, its cylinders are cheaper and charge you relatively less cost per cylinder (around $30).

Even more, you can get benefit from SodaStream’s gas exchange deal that costs $15 for a single refill. So, save your money with the Fizzi soda maker in the long run while enjoying Moe fizzy drinks.

The Winner Is: The SodaStream Fizzi

Which Drinks You Can Make With DrinkMate And SodaStream Fizzi?

Almost all people prefer a variety of flavored drinks instead of bland sparkling water. So, it does not need to taste boring. You can use different flavors and fruit syrups to enjoy a variety of bubbling water.

DrinkMate

This soda maker manufacturer does not sell any flavors and syrups. However, DrinkMate allows you to fizz almost everything else along with plain water. You can mix fruit juices available in your fridge and carbonate them. DrinkMate even allows you to add fizziness to your cocktails, mocktails, lemonade, coffee, iced tea, wine, and more.

So, you can enjoy more sparkling beverages while controlling harmful elements. You also find recipes for infusion drinks and cocktail recipes on its website. Check them out if you are interested in enjoying carbonating drinks rather than water. However, they may be a little complicated and can result in more mess. Besides, some ingredients can clog carbonator tubes.

SodaStream Fizzi

As mentioned earlier, SodaStream is a well-established company and has been in the market longer than its competitor (DrinkMate). So, you find a wide variety of flavoring syrups it sells in the market. You can choose your favorite flavor from a long list of fruit drops. SodaStream offers a root beer flavoring in sets of 4. When it’s come to soda variety, SodaStream offers more options.

Furthermore, these flavors don’t contain toxic chemicals and have less amount of sugar than market-bought sodas. So, you can enjoy a cheat day now and then. Like DrinkMate, SodaStream also shares recipes for making flavored fizzy drinks on its website. Both machines allow you to carbonate drinks other than water (neither company nor we recommend carbonating anything except water).

The Winner Is: The SodaStream Fizzi

Which Soda Maker Is Easier To Use?

Honestly, both machines are easy to use and do not involve any rocket science for their operation. You can operate them following some easy steps. Though, a minor step set them apart from each other.

DrinkMate

Although the DrinkMate does not come with a carbonating canister, it includes a fizz infuser in the box. You can attach a reusable carbonating BPA-free bottle to the carbonating soda maker machine using this fizz infuser. You don’t need to follow this extra step with SodaStream incidentally. you can follow it easily as it is not clunky. But there is a chance that you may lose or break the fizz infuser. Still, you can buy a new one from DrinkMate easily.

SodaStream Fizzi

SodaStream has more experience in the business and therefore offers more convince and easiness when it comes to using their products. You can directly attach the carbonating bottle with the SodaStream Fizzi machine without the need for a fizz infuser. Then press a single button and enjoy soda water. Indeed, SodaStream wins this round too.

The Winner Is: The SodaStream Fizzi

Are These Soda Makers Easy To Clean Too?

You don’t want messy countertops and bulky cleanup methods after preparing your drinks. Both soda makers do not involve bulky cleanup. However, one of them creates fewer spills than the other.

DrinkMate

At last, DrinkMate beats the Fizzi in this round. the fizz infuse comes with DrinkMate to avoid spills creation and prevent beverages from overflowing. So, overall cleanup is just as easy as pie. All you need to clean the fizz infuser and carbonating bottle.

SodaStream Fizzi

On the other hand, you do not get any defense such as fizz infuser against overspill. So, the chance of bubbling over and spillage is greater with the SodaStream Fizzi soda maker. More mess translates to larger cleanup. You need to clean bottles as well as the counter around your soda maker.

The Winner Is: The DrinkMate

 

Pros & Cons

DrinkMate
  • Pros:

  • Comes with an overall better and innovative design.

  • The DrinkMate is a more compact and lighter machine that translates to more portability.
  • Matches the carbonation quality of an already reputable machine (SodaStream).
  • Cons:
  • Honestly speaking, the overall cost is higher.
  • Both soda makers do not allow you to set your desired level of fizziness.
SodaStream Fizzi
  • Pros:
  • The Fizzi soda maker is easier to use as it does not need a fizz infuser for its operations.
  • You can save money in the long run with SodaStream than DrinkMate carbonator.
  • SodaStream company sells a variety of flavors, so you can enjoy more and different carbonated beverages.
  • Cons:
  • A bit bulky cleanup.

FAQs

Which is better, SodaStream or DrinkMate soda maker?

Eventually, SodaStream is better than DrinkMate in almost every category.

Are SodaStream and DrinkMate CO2 the same?

Yes, both soda makers use the same CO2 and that’s why provide the same quality of fizziness in their drinks.

What can I make with the DrinkMate maker?

You can carbonate almost anything with DrinkMate. You can add tasty Fizz to juices, coffee, iced tea, cocktails, and many more. DrinkMate allows you to explore new and more creative sparkling beverages.

Is SodaStream cheaper than buying carbonated water?

Yes, in the long run, SodaStream costs you less and allows you to save more money than that you may spend on buying carbonated water.

Is SodaStream a healthy alternative to soda?

No, it contains fewer calories than the soda you buy from stores. But being eco-friendly does not mean that it is a healthy alternative to soda.

Is there a way to refill a SodaStream bottle?

SodaStream offers eco-friendly products and focuses on using and reusing its carbonating bottles and CO2 cylinders. You can refill your CO2 canister by utilizing their gad exchange offer.

How do you remove the fizz infuser from DrinkMate?

It’s a bit complicated to remove the fizz infuser after finishing the carbonation process. All excess CO2 pressure must be released (press the blue fast release button) before you remove it from the bottle.

Final Verdict

Between the DrinkMate and Fizzi, certainly, the SodaStream Fizzi nudge it over the DrinkMate. Both machines allow you to control the ingredients of your drink and enjoy healthy beverages without excess sugar. However, SodaStream Fizzi almost wins every round. So, the clear winner of our DrinkMate vs SodaStream comparison is the SodaStream Fizzi.


Leave a Comment